
|
DCA is hosting a free online talk about loyalty programmes at 4pm (GMT) on 30 November. We’ll be sharing trends in loyalty, research findings and best practices. Register here to join. The website may give a different date but ignore that. It’s definitely on 30 November.
Wingstop UK has been on the Sunday Times’ list of the 100 fastest-growing private companies in the UK for four years running, but now, it’s focused on more than just expansion. In October, the QSR chain launched its first loyalty programme with a campaign fronted by rapper AJ Tracey.
Emma Colquhoun joined Wingstop UK as chief growth officer in January and helped. with the launch. She was previously chief marketing and commercial officer at Wagamama and chief customer officer at Krispy Kreme UK, where she also worked on loyalty programmes. She tells DCA what she’s learned about loyalty, how to design a loyalty programme to boost purchase frequency, and appealing to Gens Z and Alpha.
What was the impetus for creating the Flavour Club loyalty programme?
The first and most important reason to launch Flavour Club was to know and identify our guests and our customers because we are a heavily in-restaurant business, not an ecommerce one. We knew our transactions and we knew our sales but we didn't know our customers.
It’s super valuable, in terms of value creation, for a business to know its customer. But it’s also super important from a marketing point of view because once we know our customer, we can target our communications to them much more effectively, in a more relevant way, in a more timely way, and in the channel that's important to them.
The second reason was to drive core business performance. We've been in the market eight years and we've aggressively grown our new store openings, and we're over 100 sites now. We're at that stage in the brand's life when we need to be thinking about how we get more customers to come back more often to our existing restaurants, not just open more restaurants.
So, we're super clear that the role of Flavour Club is to drive frequency, to get those customers to come back more often. Our frequency is good. On average, customers come to Wingstop restaurants 2.2 times a year [excluding the delivery business]. But Nando’s is three times a year and KFC is higher. So we believe that there is headroom to get customers to come back more often.
The most important thing that we're focusing on is getting people to go from that first-time visit to a second one. We have around half of our customers that only come once. There's lots of reasons why they only come once. We're a more premium QSR brand, so we're more in the indulgence space, so we have a higher percentage of one-time-only customers.
On the other hand, we're a brand that really has such a big fan following. We were late to the party on loyalty, but we have over a million followers and very engaged fans. So, at the other end, we also wanted to use Flavour Club to really celebrate and bring that community together — a community of like-minded people that really want to live flavour, not just on the plate, but off the plate in terms of their life and their interests. So, part of the programme is also built to recognise that top tier of our fans that advocate for us.
Were there any arguments against introducing a loyalty programme? If so, what were they?
The counterarguments would be, when you're a low-frequency category, is it worth the effort, energy, investment, and the opportunity cost of launching a program? If you're a coffee shop or a McDonald's where you've got 18 visits a year, some would say that's more suitable for a loyalty programme than a more low-frequency brand. My counter to that is when you've got 50% of people coming only once, having a loyalty programme can absolutely nudge them to twice.
Another argument I've heard from private equity investors and other businesses is the perception that a loyalty programme is just promotional discounting in a prettier way. The customers would have come anyway. My argument to that is, if you build the construct wrong, yes. If you build it smartly, no. You can absolutely drive incremental revenue and profit.
Does the cost of the programme come out of the marketing budget and is there a healthy proportion that should generally be spent on a programme?
Yeah, it does come out of the marketing budget in the worlds that I've worked. What percentage it sits at depends on how significant it is to your overall sales. I don't think there's one best answer to that. Of course, you're always going to overinvest at the beginning to get it going. But the steady-state ratio should depend on the size of its contribution.
How did you decide on the mechanics of Flavour Club?
We did a huge amount of work on this. We looked at what everybody else was doing, but we didn't just look at food and drink. What we looked at was our audience. Wingstop is Gen Alpha- and Gen Z-focused and, for them, we came across AdiClub [Adidas’ loyalty programme] and Sephora as the two considered best-in-class. We then interrogated what makes their programs so special and so amazing. Brands often just look at their near competitors, but actually a customer is comparing you to their best experience. We also did a lot of research with our audience to understand what they would want out of a programme, and then internally we've got a lot of experience in our business of what makes a programme work.
Taking all those things, we built quite a powerful construct that first of all ladders back to what the brand stands for. I think a loyalty proposition has to absolutely personify what your brand stands for, and our brand stands for flavour and living flavour. We know that, with our brand, when people buy across more flavours, they come more frequently. Hence the whole construct of the programme of flavour discovery and flavour variety.
Also, I think the best programs have the right balance between transactional loyalty and emotional loyalty. I think programs that are just transactional do risk being promotions in disguise and the programs that only focus on emotion miss the fundamental hygiene factors. So that's what Flavour Club does. The transaction is a stamp-based programme. We went for stamps rather than points because we're trying to drive frequency. We're not trying to get people to spend more when they come with us. We're trying to get people to come more often. When you do transactional loyalty, it's really important that it's super simple for customers. So we arrived at four stamps for a free side, and eight stamps for a free main, based on our average basket size and based on what our top typical customers do and what would make sense to give away.
Birthday offers are one of the strongest and most compelling in the loyalty world, so we wanted to make sure we were generous on birthdays as well. That's why we added that as the final piece of transactional loyalty.
When it comes to emotional loyalty, we wanted to do two things. We wanted to weave in an element of surprise and delight because we know that creates active engagement. For me, sign-up numbers are vanity metrics. What really matters is how many people are actively engaged in the programme. So, we have things like monthly flavour drops, which are always experiences, money-can't-buy items. They'll never be discounts. They're things that have value to our customers that you can't get anywhere else. But [customers] have to be active in 90 days to take part in those. So, that's how we're trying to drive the behaviour.
We also had this idea of being an OG, an original. So, the first 5,000 people that got engaged in the programme and started using it got an amazing piece of merch. That was an investment in the programme, to show how we show up, leveraging merch and not just value discounting. But it was also a very intentional way to create that behaviour quickly in the programme because we knew that if we can get people to go from that first visit to a second visit within 90 days, their lifetime value is so much higher.
Are there any loyalty programme mistakes that you’ve made in the past that you’ve learned from?
At Krispy Kreme, we probably focused too much on transactional loyalty. We had a points-based programme, but then we overlaid lots of discounts because it's so tempting to do it. But then I think we ended up in a world where the incremental profit of the programme was compromised a little. Then at Wagamama, we'd started the programme far too heavy on emotional loyalty and hadn't got the base hygiene factors in, and it was too elaborate on being a personification of the brand and over complicated. So hopefully I've got the right balance with Flavour Club.
Something I was taught by a lady that did digital transformation at L’Oréal, which has been so powerful for me, is that the way to make a programme successful is always to think, what customer behaviour do you want? If you think about the customer behaviour you want, you won't go wrong in how you build a loyalty programme. And that's the mantra I live by.
Are there any new technologies or customer behaviours you must consider now when building a loyalty programme?
It comes down to the audience. At both my other brands, we had a full-blown app because that's what the audience wanted. At Wingstop, we have a digi-wallet with a web app portal attached to it. And the reason why we went for a digi-wallet is because that's what our audience wants. Gen Z don't want to have loads of apps downloaded but they engage with their wallets every day. But then, we couldn't add the engagement [elements of the programme] without adding a web app interactive portal as well. So, being able to do that now and still having the same rich experience wouldn't have been possible seven years ago. Now tech has advanced so you can meet customers where they are and where they expect to find you but still give that engaging experience.
The other thing that has evolved is personalisation. I don't mean personalisation of discounts. I mean, how the app shows up with dedicated visuals or dishes or items that only you buy. I think McDonald's are best-in-class in this space and that's been such a progression in the last three years.
The final piece that I think we're all just starting to grapple with is the power of AI in analytics. Harnessing data is always one of the pain points once you've launched a programme. You've got all this wonderful data, but what do you do with it? I think AI is starting to be a game-changer in that.
Has AI helped you with analytics at Wingstop yet?
We used a synthetic audience to build the programme. We work with a company called Electric Twin. And I worked with them not because I wanted to bring AI into the business but because I wanted to bring the customer voice into the boardroom. Back in the day you used to have an empty chair in the boardroom, and you’d go, ‘That's Bob, the customer.’
Now I can literally use the synthetic audience to answer questions and run focus groups within five minutes in a boardroom where the decisions are being made.
Can you tell us anything about the targets you have set for the programme or the results you’ve seen so far?
I can’t give the numbers but I would want to be represented as a leader that builds programmes for commercial value, builds out of customer insights and puts customers at the heart of that growth. That's a really important part of who I am as a leader.
Do you think that loyalty now plays a bigger role within brands? If so, any pet theories about why that might be?
Yeah, I do agree. I think it’s an offshoot of the digital transformation journey we saw five or six years ago in marketing. When you move into a digital era of marketing, the need to be able to use data and to personalise that in a relevant way is the heart and soul of what marketing of the next generation needs to be. So I think it's the heartbeat of the next chapter of marketing. It is quite hard to get customer data and that single customer view to be the narrative of a business, though. Especially for established industries that live on sales data. It's a big culture change. That's why I think it hasn't fully landed in every business yet.
How did you like today's newsletter?
Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Sign up to get it in your inbox.

